INKPOT#37 CLASSICAL MUSIC FEATURE: SIBELIUS The Fifth Symphony – Recordings Survey
Recordings Survey Part 1
Last update: 2 May 2000 by the Inkpot Sibelius Nutcasetm
with warmest regards to my good friend Francisco Simn
In approximate order of RECORDING
Please note that CD timings indicate only duration of Symphony No.5 on record.
[186:48] mid-price. Symphony No.5 (29’05”) recorded June 1932 (released 1992). MONO.
EMI Classics Karajan Edition CDM5 66600-2
[78:23] mid-price. Symphony No.5 (32’32”) recorded Jul 1952 (released 1998). MONO.
As far as I know this is Karajan’s first recording (of four) of the Fifth. The winds sound rather scrawny due to the monophonic sound, but wonderful sound it is nonetheless. The reading of the symphony already shows Karajan’s deep understanding of the music, displayed in the natural grasp of the symphony’s details, lines and dynamic expressions. The duration of this performance is on the long side (but it’s only 1952 and not many recordings exist) – Karajan takes his time to build up the first movement up to the swelling climax – and well done it is. The conclusion of the first movement is a master model of its kind – here, in this gorgeous 1952 mono recording – just listen to those details and the power driving them. A majestic and exciting Finlandia opens the disc with heartfelt patroitism.
Royal Stockholm Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Sixten Ehrling
[217:40] full-price (3CD set). Symphony No.5 (27’19”) recorded Jan 1953 (part of first complete cycle on record). Reissued 1999.
Though the style of interpretation is more towards the direct and straightforward type, the results are surprisingly amiable. The first movement is full of confidence and strength, with firmness of expression. It has an unfaltering flow which is continued in the Andante – it sounds like there is a little too much momentum and speed, but it still sounds right. It is like perceiving a river’s flow – it may seem too fast, yet it is natural in feel. The finale is energetic, the Swan Hymn extraordinarly beautiful and heartfelt despite the old recording. Although the remastering (or the instruments) experience a little strained harmony, the effect remains grand. Throughout, once again, Ehrling’s sense of momentum does not lapse.
EMI Classics Karajan Edition CDM5 66599-2
[77:04] mid-price. Symphony No.5 (30’54”) recorded Sep 1960.
Karajan recorded the symphony again with the Philharmonia in 1960. This unfortunately, is It opens well, and is just as fine until the flute spoils the picture with a strained note or two. The performance is slightly wanting in concentration for the first third of the movement, though the orchestra plays with marvellous skill throughout the symphony.
The first big climax near the beginning does not quite have the swell and burst of light which distinguishes the Berlin 1965 recording. Nevertheless, the point where the two original movements were joined (around 8’46”) is beautifully executed by Karajan. In the monumental conclusion, the Philharmonia rises to the occasion with a glorious blaze of brass. The precision of their playing, along with the pulsating horns in the background, provide an exciting ending. (Extract from full review).
|Click to Return to the Classical Index!…
or Visit the Inkvault archives!
375/079a: 30.12.98 Inkpot Sibelius Nutcase