Concert Review: Bernstein Chichester Psalms, Mahler Symphony No. 6 – Orchestra of the Music Makers, Lü Shao-Chia | The Flying Inkpot

Bernstein – Chichester Psalms *
Mahler – Symphony No. 6 in A minor
I. Allegro energico, ma non troppo. Heftig, aber markig.
II. Scherzo: Wuchtig
III. Andante moderato
IV. Finale: Sostenuto – Allegro moderato – Allegro energico
Joel Cheong Hsin Ern, boy soprano *
Voices of Singapore *
Chong Wai Lun, chorus master *
Orchestra of the Music Makers
Lü Shao-Chia, conductor
Esplanade Concert Hall
7:30 pm, 13 July 2024
Review by Derek Lim
This evening’s pairing of Leonard Bernstein’s short but meaningful Chichester Psalms against the work of a composer he often championed, Mahler’s Symphony No.6, was a brilliant bit of concert programming.
Written in 1965, Bernstein was pleading, in the Psalms, for peace in Israel, then – as it is now – embroiled in regional conflict. Featuring the Voices of Singapore choir, prepared by chorus master Chong Wai Lun, the joint forces with the Orchestra of the Music Makers (OMM) under 64-year-old conductor Lü Shao-chia made a joyful noise with sparkling, precise rhythms in the first movement. The second movement, with 12-year-old Joel Cheong Hsin Ern’s clear, bell-like boy soprano in ‘Adonai ro-i, io eshar’(‘The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want’) was lovingly phrased, with a rapt chorus-and-string entry, while the final movement’s string-only introduction – weighty and solemnly played – gave way to a beautiful ‘Hineh mah tov’ (‘Behold how good/And how pleasant it is/For brethren to dwell/Together in unity’).
With its more universal message of brethren dwelling together in unity, the Psalms were the perfect complement to Mahler’s much more individual journey of struggle in his Sixth Symphony. I’ve never understood why the Sixth is less popular than, say, his fourth symphony. Sure, it ends tragically (for the hero), but there is so much life force in this symphony – from the exhilarating coda with the ‘Alma’ theme in the first movement, and even (perhaps especially), the fight that is ever-present in the Finale.
Lü led the OMM in a fleet-footed, technically accomplished performance that emphasised the symphony’s Classical form over drama. Eschewing the more dramatic excesses of conductors such as Bernstein or Tennstedt, he led the excellent OMM in crackling form, highlighting the long line, downplaying the moulding of phrases, and generally preventing the music from sounding episodic as it might have under less seasoned conductors.
The first movement, in particular, was an exciting, clearly mapped-out X-ray of the sonata form. Briskly taken and with trenchant strings leading the march, it clocked in at a mere 22 minutes even with exposition repeat. With excellent playing throughout, there was much to enjoy, not least in the feisty brass and gutsy percussion sounding out the major-to-minor triad over the timpani-and-snare drum march rhythm.

This swiftness was sometimes at the expense of drama: I missed the feeling of repose and relaxation in the important ‘Alpine’ episode. Often taken at a dreamlike pace to make a point of its otherworldliness and detachment, here, Lü scarcely slowed down. The cowbells here were rather too soft to be appreciated, but moving solos from the principal flute and the concertmaster, Chan Yong-Han, made up for this.
Architecturally, Lü seemed to downplay the first movement coda, stripping it of some of its jubilation, placing the balance of the symphony in favour of the Finale, but also reduced the contrast between the symphony’s greatest peak in the triumph of the first movement, which the hero fights for, against his eventual downfall.
His treatment of the two middle movements – here played Scherzo [11”] first, then Andante moderato [13”] – was equally brisk. I felt as if Lü sees these two middle movements as lighter movements contrasting against the darker outer ones.
Rhythmically tight and well-characterized in the pounding main Scherzo theme, the second Altväterish theme felt somewhat underdeveloped by contrast. Perhaps it was because of the sheer fleetness of the tempo, but the dark, gothic, macabre nature of this movement felt underplayed, and the poisonous sting of the winds in this ‘horror Scherzo’ muted. While the ability to play beautifully is always appreciated, some passages could have benefitted from an ugly sound.
The desolate Andante moderato, played here more as an interlude than a central oasis of repose, had beautiful solos from the cor anglais and horn. With a clear eye on the beauty rather than the drama of the movement, Lü kept the music moving, sometimes not allowing one phrase to completely resolve before rushing to the next. One wished he had allowed more time for the searing climax, with its cowbells sounding against soaring, yearning strings, to make its mark.

Lü’s long-line approach continued into the Finale [28”]. Mustering his huge forces, this was again a clear-headed, cogent reading which was very much in keeping with his treatment of the rest of the symphony. Eschewing from whipping up the music, he succeeded in keeping up the musicians’ energy (particularly that of the all-important brass) through this very long movement, right to the end.
This was riveting stuff, with each section playing their hearts out, especially the valiant strings. Delivering climax after climax, the gutsy OMM seemed paradoxically energised and refocused after each of the two mighty hammer blows instead of being beaten down in battle, making the final doom-laden coda with its shocking final fortissimo A-minor chord that much more tragic. The final pizzicati, played piano, was shorn of all rhetoric – death had come, ending a daring, memorable performance of this difficult symphony.
![]()




